When every supplier quote is over target cost, should you change the drawing?
Before asking engineering to relax a tolerance, check which drawing revision and order quantity each supplier priced. A bracket example shows who needs to requote.
Three machine shops have quoted above target cost. Do you ask engineering to loosen a tolerance, or ask a shop to quote again? If all three priced the current drawing at the first-order quantity, revisiting the design makes sense. If one sent a production-volume price for an older drawing, start with the request for quotation.
The locomotive maker that went back to its parts list
In a 2016 article, Boston Consulting Group describes a locomotive manufacturer facing lower-cost competitors and new regulatory requirements. A cross-functional team worked back from its selling price and target margin to set budgets for materials and labor. Product teardowns revealed expensive features with limited customer value. The team explored standardizing parts and simplifying its catalog. A buyer negotiating against the original parts list would have had little room to propose those changes.1
Consider a tight tolerance on a drawing. A quote alone cannot tell the buyer whether that tolerance protects a safety function or carried over from the previous model. The engineer can explain why the dimension matters. The machinist can explain whether meeting it requires another operation. Together, their answers give the buyer a choice that a price comparison cannot surface on its own.
Which supplier needs to requote before engineering revisits the design?
In Kairen Covenant’s fictional bracket demo, the buyer needs 300 units of Rev C. Supplier A’s lower price of ₩18,000 is for 1,000 units of Rev B. Supplier B quoted ₩21,000 for the 300 units of Rev C the buyer can actually order. Put those terms side by side and a specific question comes before any change to the hole position. What would A charge for 300 units of Rev C?
If the like-for-like quotes still exceed the target, the engineer and the machinist have a reason to examine which requirement adds an operation. Compare supplier quotes by drawing revision and quantity in Kairen Covenant
Notes
- The locomotive example appears in BCG’s discussion of target costing. The three quotations and tolerance question illustrate a buyer’s decision. BCG article ↩
References
- The Design-to-Value Advantage: Developing Winning Products with the Best Economics. Boston Consulting Group, 2016-01-19.
Cite this article
Kairen. “When every supplier quote is over target cost, should you change the drawing?.” Kairen Insights, November 21, 2026. https://kairenhq.com/insights/when-the-drawing-sets-the-price
About Kairen
Kairen builds sourcing software for product teams and suppliers to agree on part specs, prices, and delivery dates as designs take shape.
Explore Kairen Covenant